Blogs at Penn State Community

I have my blog set to allow anonymous comments and require email address for anonymous comments, but when I have a "trusted commenter" post a comment, it still requires my approval. Under the comments settings, I have Immediately Approve comments from: "Trusted commenters only" set. However, I still seem to need to approve those comments, even when they are my own.

How can I allow the world to comment, forcing them to put their email, but then allowing some to become trusted?